Error correction in the English classroom: when and how to correct
Which errors to correct, when to correct them, techniques you can use straight away, and who should do the correcting.
Every teacher faces the same questions when a learner makes a mistake. Should I correct it? Now or later? How? And who should do the correcting? There’s no single right answer, and the research doesn’t always agree. But correction that suits the error, the learner and the moment is generally considered helpful, and many learners expect it.
In this guide you’ll find a practical way to think about error correction: which errors to focus on, when to correct, a set of techniques you can use straight away, and how to keep correction positive. You can also download the free error correction handout as a PDF.
Errors and mistakes
Teachers sometimes separate two kinds of incorrect language:
- Errors come from a gap in knowledge. The learner can’t correct them alone.
- Mistakes (or slips) happen under pressure or when the learner is tired or distracted. The learner can usually correct them once they’re pointed out.
In practice, it’s often hard to tell them apart unless you know the learner well or give them a chance to correct themselves. So in this guide, we use the two words loosely.
It also helps to think about the impact of an error. Some get in the way of understanding (I have be no English class). Others don’t affect communication much (She like study English). And errors don’t only affect grammar. They can affect meaning, form, pronunciation or appropriacy, for example a request in a restaurant that comes across as rude. Appropriacy is easy to overlook, but it can matter a lot to the learner.
Deciding whether to correct
Not every error needs correcting, and correcting everything can be counterproductive. Teachers often focus on errors that:
- make it hard to understand what the learner means
- relate to the focus of the lesson
- come up again and again
- are made by many learners in the class
- could lead to the learner being laughed at or misunderstood outside class
Slips made under pressure, and errors in language well above the learner’s level, are often less useful to correct.
Think about the person, too. Correcting a shy learner who has just found the courage to speak, or someone sharing something personal, may do more harm than good. Where possible, find out how your learners feel about correction and adapt to them.
When to correct: now or later?
There’s no clear agreement on whether immediate or delayed correction works better. A common approach is:
- During accuracy-focused activities, such as a controlled practice exercise, correct straight away.
- During fluency-focused activities, such as a discussion, listen, note useful errors and deal with them afterwards, so you don’t interrupt communication.
That said, a quick, light correction during a speaking activity can also work well, because learners are focused on meaning and may notice the gap more easily. If you do correct during fluency work, keep it brief and unobtrusive.
Error correction techniques
Imagine a learner says: He’s richest man in the world! Here are some ways you could respond.
| Technique | What you do |
|---|---|
| Clarification request | Act as if you didn’t quite catch it: Sorry, can you say that again? |
| Repetition | Repeat the sentence with rising intonation: He’s richest man…? |
| Partial repetition | Repeat up to the error and pause: He’s… |
| Elicitation | Say there’s a mistake and invite another try: Nearly! Can you try again? |
| Language clue | Give a hint using grammar terms: It’s a superlative. What do we need before the adjective? |
| Options | Offer a choice: Richest, the richest or a richest? |
| Gesture or expression | A puzzled look or a wobble of the hand, then let the learner try again. |
| Finger correction | Use one finger per word to show where something is missing. |
| Board work | Write the sentence on the board so the learner can see and fix the error. |
| Recast | Repeat the sentence correctly, perhaps stressing the change: Yes, he’s THE richest man in the world. |
| Explicit correction | Point out the mistake and give the correct form. |
| Ignore it for now | Note it down and come back to it later. |
Some techniques give learners the correct form (recasts, explicit correction). They’re quick, but learners may not notice a recast at all. Others ask learners to find the correct form themselves (elicitation, clues, repetition). These take more time, but they involve learners more and help them notice. They only work, though, if the learner knows the correct form.
A useful habit is to start light and move to more explicit techniques if needed. A raised eyebrow or a partial repetition gives the learner a chance to fix the error themselves. If that doesn’t work, a clue or an explicit correction makes sure it’s dealt with.
Who corrects?
- Self-correction encourages learners to think, but can be frustrating if they don’t know the answer.
- Peer correction gets the class involved, but can be embarrassing for some learners.
- Teacher correction is accurate, but can make learners rely on you.
Giving the learner the first chance is often a good idea, but it isn’t a rule. Choose what suits the error and the learner.
Tips for error correction that helps
- Be selective. Focusing on a few important errors usually works better than correcting everything.
- Make sure learners notice. A correction learners don’t recognise as a correction won’t help much.
- Give thinking time. Let learners try to fix the error before you step in.
- Don’t insist. If a learner can’t or doesn’t want to repeat the correct form, move on. Repeating it once doesn’t mean they’ve learned it.
- Balance correction with praise. Point out good language as well as errors, and avoid ending a lesson with a long list of mistakes.
Correction is part of most lesson shapes, from the feedback stage in a task-based speaking lesson to the practice stages of PPP.
Error correction FAQ
Should teachers correct every mistake?
Usually not. Correcting every mistake can affect learners’ confidence and makes it harder for them to see which errors matter most. Focusing on errors that affect meaning, relate to your aims or come up often tends to be more useful.
Is it better to correct errors immediately or later?
It depends on the activity. Many teachers correct immediately during accuracy work and later during fluency work. Brief, light correction during speaking can also work, as long as it doesn’t stop the conversation.
What is a recast in error correction?
A recast is when the teacher repeats what the learner said, but correctly, without pointing out the error directly. It’s quick and natural, but learners don’t always notice it.
How do I correct errors in writing?
Many of the same principles apply: be selective and focus on your aims. Codes or underlining that ask learners to find and fix their own errors can work well, especially when learners write a second draft.
Download the error correction handout
The free PDF handout covers types and sources of errors, how to decide whether to correct, all the correction techniques with examples, and the pros and cons of self-, peer and teacher correction. It’s free to print and share. Download the error correction handout (PDF), or browse more teaching skills resources.
From idea to a complete lesson in seconds
All you need is a clear aim, your learners’ level and your teaching context. You make the teaching decisions; eltMate does the heavy lifting.
Try eltMate free25,000 free credits on signup. No card needed.
Want more ideas like this?
Get practical teaching tips, new guides and free handouts by email. It’s free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
We’ll send you an email to confirm. See our Privacy Policy.